After Dawson’s Creek wrapped in 2003, James Van Der Beek took a while to find his footing. There was The Plague , a direct-to-video horror flick produced by Clive Barker about kids mysteriously falling into comas. There was Final Draft , a similarly questionable horror movie about a writer who loses his mind trying to pen a script about a killer clown. He played a doctor on the medical drama Mercy and a psychotic killer with multiple personalities on the CBS procedural Criminal Minds . But