How did the Gaza ceasefire happen? The anti-Israel left, and Democrats rushing to explain why former president Joe Biden could not achieve it, have invented the phony argument one can find prominently displayed in a New York Times "analysis" that asks, "Why Now?" and in the sanctimonious X threads of former Biden officials explaining how they laid the groundwork for this historic deal. It goes like this: Biden offered similar ceasefire plans a year ago. The hostages would have been home in 2024,