The first time Alexa Rockwell went to vote for her favorite contestant on American Idol this season, she found the voting methods — especially the newly implemented process of casting votes via social media — unnecessarily complicated. It immediately turned her off. “It gets a little messy,” says Rockwell, a lifelong Idol fan who has watched and voted since the show’s first season. “It’s like, if it’s not broke, don’t fix it.” Rockwell remembers learning how to make a phone call during the