This spring, every graduation speech seemed to pick a side on AI. Either AI is threatening everything that makes us human, and we should be afraid. Or human creativity is irreplaceable, and we should be hopeful. Both takes have produced standing ovations and nearly the same advice: stay curious, stay human. But despite the thoughtful speeches about the future, we all continue to miss a fundamental question: what is the impact of AI on how we know ourselves and what we believe? We are not