‘Tis the season for the hottest dinner table debate: Apple or pumpkin pie? While there might not be anything quite as American as apple pie, for a small sliver of the year, the classic dessert gets edged out by a seasonal star featuring the orange gourd. At Hoosier Mama Pie Company in Chicago, apple pie is the top seller for most of the year.  “It is the only pie we bake out of season because there would be a riot if we did not have apple pie,” chef and owner Paula Haney told Fox News Digital.