He didn’t do it, he promises! Photo: Netflix Babe, Wake Up , there’s a Dead Man . The newest Knives Out Mystery is set in a church, starring a hot priest and Andrew Scott. But somehow the hot priest is not played by Andrew Scott. Challengers star Josh O’Connor is the daddy father at the center of Benoit Blanc’s newest mystery. Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin), whom O’Connor’s Reverend Jud Duplenticy hated, is dead. “Everything thinks I did it,” O’Connor says in the November 17 trailer. “